Annuity Guys®

Annuity Rates, Features & Ratings: America's trusted annuity resource. Compare best options for hybrid, index, fixed, variable & immediate annuity quotes.


Helping You Create Great Results Your Retirement Deserves!



(217)753-1515
  • Home
  • About Us
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Site Terms & Disclosure
    • Privacy Policy
  • FAQs
    • Most Frequently Asked Annuity Questions
  • All Annuity Guys Videos
  • Annuity Types
    • Best Annuity Reviews
    • Market Free™ Annuities
    • Choosing an Annuity
    • Deferred Annuities
    • Hybrid Annuity Choices
      • Hybrid Annuity Pros&Cons
      • Hybrid Income Riders
      • Hybrid Annuity Guarantees & Strategies
    • Fixed Annuity Choices
      • Fixed Annuity Performance
      • Better Fixed Annuities
      • Fixed Deferred Annuities
      • Fixed Rate Annuities
      • Fixed Annuity Alternatives
      • Fixed Annuity Pros & Cons
      • Fixed Annuity Negatives
    • Index Annuity Choices
      • Fixed Index Annuity Features
      • Fixed Index Annuity Performance
      • Better Fixed Index Annuities
      • Fixed Index Annuity Alternatives
      • Fixed Index Annuity Pros & Cons
      • Fixed Index Annuity History
      • Fixed Index Annuity Negatives
    • Immediate Annuities
      • Immediate Variable Annuity
      • Immediate Fixed Annuities
    • Variable Annuities
      • Variable Annuity Features
      • Better Variable Annuities
      • Variable Annuities Disadvantages
      • Variable Annuity Alternatives
      • Variable Annuity Negatives
      • Variable Annuity Performance
    • Pre-Issued Annuities™
      • Hybrid Annuities versus Pre-Issued Annuities ™
    • Annuity Glossary
  • Articles
    • How Do MarketFree™ Annuities Work?
    • Are Annuities Safe?
    • Living Benefits
    • FIA Performance
    • Beware of FIAs?
    • Annuities & Retirement
    • Annuities & Estate Tax
    • Rollovers & Annuities
    • Annuities & Tax
    • Charity & Annuities
    • The Lost Decade
    • Best Annuity Videos
    • Social Security Benefits
  • Calculators
    • Retirement Planning Calculator — Basic
    • Retirement Shortfall Calculator — Basic
    • Immediate Annuity Calculator & Quotes
    • Fixed Index Annuity Calculator & Fixed Annuity Calculator
    • Variable Annuity Calculator & Hybrid Annuity Calculator
  • Blog
    • Annuity Guys® Weekly Annuity Video Blogs
  • Get Annuity Guys Help
    • Request Annuity Guys’ Planning Help Today
You are here: Home / Annuity Commentary / Is an Old Variable Annuity Better than a New Hybrid?

Is an Old Variable Annuity Better than a New Hybrid?

November 16, 2012 By Annuity Guys®

“Don’t buy an annuity! The **guarantees they offer are often unnecessary and costly.” – has turned into “that annuity sure saved you from the market meltdown!”; and “you’d better hang on to it!”

So, can today’s annuity buyer expect the same performance from an annuity they could have purchased a few years back? Eric and Dick discuss the variable annuities  of yesteryear and how they compare to the hybrid annuities and variable annuities# of today.

[embedit snippet=”video-specialist-button-hybrid”]

 

**Guarantees, including optional benefits, are backed by the claims-paying ability of the issuer, and may contain limitations, including surrender charges, which may affect policy values. During this segment, Dick and Eric are referring to Fixed Annuities unless otherwise specified.

A New Twist on Variable Annuities

Variable annuities draw fierce debate from both advocates and skeptics alike. But whether you like the **guaranteed benefits that they offer or think that they cost too much for the protection they provide, one thing is clear: Those who bought variable annuities# with **guarantee provisions five years ago got a screaming deal.

Plunging markets showed off the best attributes of variable annuities# with **guarantee provisions. Now, Hartford Financial is making an interesting offer to some of its variable annuity# holders: It’s trying to buy them out.

The pros and cons of variable annuities#

The reason financial experts on both sides of the variable annuity# debate have such strong reactions to the products is that they offer an unusual set of reward characteristics. On one hand, variable annuities# often give policyholders upside potential similar to that of mutual fund^s, ETFs, or other pooled investments. Yet the insurance aspect of annuities adds the ability to provide additional **guarantees, which regular mutual fund^s and ETFs can’t do. The view that opponents take, on the other hand, is that these **guarantees are often unnecessary and are usually costly. With annual expense ratios for variable annuities# typically well above what a similar mutual fund^ or ETF would charge, the **guarantees they offer definitely come with a cost — and under ordinary market conditions, the cost often exceeds the benefit.

How the market meltdown hurt insurers Over the past several years, though, market conditions have been anything but normal. A more than 50% plunge in the stock market from late 2007 to the market’s bottom in early 2009. [Read More…]

 by Dan Caplinger of Fool.com on November 15, 2012

Annuity Guys® Video Transcript:

Dick: We have a real twist on things, Eric. The same folks that we’re advising everyone not to buy a variable annuity#, we don’t get into the variable annuity# as much as we do the hybrid annuity, but a lot of the folks that were talking bad stuff about the variable annuity# . . .

Eric: Saying nasty things about buying a variable?

Dick: We’re seeing this change of events. Were the **guarantees were so good in the variable annuities# of yesteryear, that nowadays, the same guys that were basically saying, “Don’t buy those. They’re just paying high commissions to insurance agents,” are now basically saying, “If you’ve got one of those variable annuities#, do not let it go.”

Eric: The **guarantees you’ve got there, nobody can beat that. I don’t know how you did that. It’s interesting, because we say . . . In the fund thing in this article, they talked about, “The **guarantees were often unnecessary and costly.” Guess what, it’s **guarantees. Why is it you’re . . .

Dick: They’re not unnecessary when they’re necessary.

Eric: They weren’t costly when they saved your butt.

Dick: Exactly, when it became a great deal. That’s where we always say that hindsight’s 20/20. All the experts seem to agree, and then find out later that they’re wrong.

Eric: That’s where when we talk about annuity, you talk about the **guarantees. If you can live with the minimum **guarantee, you know exactly what you’re going to get, and you’re happy with that, anything beyond that is icing.

Dick: Right. I personally, Eric, have talked to several folks that have called in and described their variable annuity# to me. They’ve said, “It’s got a 6% death benefit. It’s got a 6% withdrawal rate that I’m taking out. I’ll get my principle back. I can take 6% out.”

Eric: We can’t get those right now.

Dick: Yeah. We tell those people typically, “Unless there’s some great extenuating circumstances, don’t give that up.” That is a very good **guarantee, and they don’t do that anymore.

Eric: Right. Some of them . . . if you bought it when the market was going gangbusters, and you had that annual lock-in or those ratchets, so it locked in at that high watermark . . .

Dick: Right. You’re working off of that now.

Eric: Then ‘shh’.

Dick: Yeah, going up from there.

Eric: Everything else going down. Now it keeps building off of that.

Dick: Yes. The variable annuity# companies, they looked at past performance. They did their actuarial studies, and they said, “Based on this, we can offer these contractual **guarantees.” What do they tell us about past performance?

Eric: Never predict future performance. Never **guarantee future performance based on the past.

Dick: Exactly. Here they are caught in their own dilemma of future performance not matching past performance, so they’re all scaling back.

Eric: We should make the point that these companies that are trying to buy out of their **guarantees, it’s not at risk to the consumer.

Dick: True.

Eric: What these companies are trying to do, they’re just trying to become more profitable, because they have to dedicate a whole lot more assets reserving for those **guarantees. They can take those dollars and use them in more profitable divisions, typically, property casually and those other areas. Those are the companies that are saying, “We can make more money by putting our dollars someplace else.” Your annuities, if you’re in one of those companies that is looking at maybe buying you out . . .

Dick: Think twice.

Eric: First of all, I don’t know if it’s a great option to buy it out. You have to weigh that very carefully, as well.

Dick: Get with an adviser that can really look at it closely and say, “This is a good one. Keep it.” That doesn’t mean that all of the older annuities are good.

Eric: Right. There’s some bad ones.

Dick: Yes, there are. Yet, if you’re looking for a new annuity, there are newer annuities, and this is where we get back into the hybrid or the fixed, because they weren’t investing in the stock market or riskier investments. They’re putting the money from those annuities into bonds and very high-grade investments, US treasuries, so they weren’t hit with the same things that variable annuity# companies have been, and their contractual **guarantees are, in many case, equal to or better than what some of the past variable annuity# **guarantees were.

Eric: Those are really the new style that we like, that typically took some of those best components from those old variables, those income riders and those income **guarantees, and then added those to a fixed component. That’s where we see a lot of the move in today, where if you’re looking at an annuity today, those fixed or hybrid annuities with indexing components to get better returns.

Dick: They give you those contractual **guarantees that the old variable annuities# gave us. I guess, nobody really knows the future, but I’m going to go out on a limb here and predict something. It’s like when we look at ourselves in a mirror, Eric; we are all guilty of it. We look back 2 or 3 years ago and we go, “Wow. I was a lot thinner then. I was a lot younger then. I wish I could go back to that.” I predict that if things continue on with the type of economy and headwinds we’ve had, that we’ll look back at today’s annuities and we’ll go, “Wow. What if I would have got that setup then?” It’s that way each year that goes along, as long as there are some good contractual **guarantees. If we can lock into those and we’re satisfied with those, a lot of times later on, we can look back and go, “Wow. That was a good move.”

Eric: Yeah, I agree. It’s being satisfied with the **guarantee, as long as that . . . Are you going to answer the question? Are the old ones better than the new ones?

Dick: Many times, we end with a statement that basically says, ‘It’s depends’, and it does depend. You really do have to look at it and determine it. Most the time on an older variable annuity#, going back maybe 3 or 4 years, where that annuity had some good riders on it, there’s a pretty good chance that you don’t want to give that annuity up. On the other hand, if we’re looking at some of these newer annuities, and maybe yours was quite a bit older or you didn’t get the riders on it . . .

Eric: Don’t have the **guarantee.

Dick: Right. Or you just can’t live with the idea that your principle’s at risk and it can go backwards, there can be some reasons to change up to a newer annuity.

Eric: In hindsight, basically, or in retrospect, some of the old ones are good and some of the new ones are good; some of the old ones are bad and some of the new ones are bad. You had it, we summarized it.

Dick: That’s right.

Eric: Thanks for checking us out today.

Dick: Thank you.

1.2k
SHARES
ShareTweetGoogleLinkedinPinterestSkypeStumbleuponTumblrDeliciousDiggRedditMail

Filed Under: Annuity Commentary, Annuity Guys Video, Hybrid Annuities, Variable Annuities Tagged With: annuities, Annuity, Annuity Buyers, Buy Variable Annuities, Equity-indexed Annuity, Guarantees, Hybrid Annuity, retirement, Variable Annuity

About Annuity Guys®

Annuity Guys®, Dick & Eric, enjoy entertaining you with their off-beat sense of humor, lighthearted sarcasm, and no shortage of expertise on annuities as they discuss today's retirement challenges. Got annuity questions... they've got annuity answers!

 

Empowering Annuity Reference Book

 
DOWN-LOAD NOW - FREE!
  • Annuity Guys Reference Book - 250 pages of Annuity Facts

  • "The New Retirement"
    Annuity Reference Book 
    Free Instant Download
  • Confidential - Easy Opt Out

 

  • How Much Income Can You Withdraw Safely in Retirement?

    How Much Income Can You Withdraw Safely in Retirement?

    A Reuter’s article hit our desk recently. It’s based on a “safe withdrawal rate” during retirement (safe being relative since we’re …Read More »
  • Can Hybrid Annuities Beat Market Returns?

    Can Hybrid Annuities Beat Market Returns?

    Do you remember the story of the tortoise and the hare? Hybrid annuities might be compared to the tortoise in …Read More »
  • Annuity Timing – Jump in or Wait?

    Annuity Timing – Jump in or Wait?

    Annuity Guys®, Dick and Eric examine the question on the mind of many people when comes to selecting an annuity …Read More »

Revealing Fun Video: Fiduciary Advisors Vs. Annuity Salesmen
MUST KNOW FACTS 90% of
ANNUITY ADVISORS AVOID TELLING!
  • *FIDUCIARY RETIREMENT REVIEWS
    Second Opinions Improve Retirements
     
    "For Your Retirement's Success"
     Choose a *Fiduciary Advisor who gives you Full Disclosure of Cost & Selection.
     
    Material Fact 1:
      About 90% of advisors ARE NOT REQUIRED by law to do what is best for their clients!
     
    Material Fact 2:
     Fiduciary Advisors ARE REQUIRED by law to do what's best for their clients! 
     
      Hence, clients of a fiduciary can know that their advisor chose the highest legal standard required by law to work strictly for their highest good.
     
     We estimate Fiduciaries are less than 10% of total U.S. financial service providers. Fiduciaries are held to the highest client legal standard of financial planning and investment advice.
     
     The other 90% are sales oriented advisors, brokers, bank reps, registered reps. & insurance agents, selling products on a much lower suitability legal standard, not necessarily what's best for their client!
     
       Fiduciaries also must disclose conflicts of interest that could potentially bias their advice, such as; selling products that pay them higher commissions having higher fees or costs, and their lack of investment product access limiting their client's opportunities, to name a few.
     
    Choosing your advisor can have
    "The Largest Single Impact on
    Your Retirement's Success or Failure"


  • Five Top Annuity Safety Risks to Avoid

    Five Top Annuity Safety Risks to Avoid

    Annuities are safe, secure and without risk…. hmm, well not exactly. As Annuity Guys® we expound quite a bit on the safety …Read More »
  • Is an Annuity the Wrong Choice for You?

    Is an Annuity the Wrong Choice for You?

    Should I or shouldn’t I – that is the question.Many of our site visitors struggle with the decision to choose an annuity …Read More »
  • Annuity Income Riders

    Annuity Income Riders

    What makes a newer hybrid style income annuity different from the industry standard, immediate income annuity? It’s the income rider!Everyone …Read More »
  • Variable Annuities Vs Fixed Index Annuities – FIAs

    Variable Annuities Vs Fixed Index Annuities – FIAs

    Suze Orman came by the office the other day… Okay, true confession, so, she was actually on the cover of an …Read More »
  • The New – Immediate Hybrid Annuity™

    The New – Immediate Hybrid Annuity™

    What could be better than a Hybrid Annuity? How about a New – Immediate Hybrid Annuity™!For a typical retiree with …Read More »
  • Turning Your 401k into Retirement Income

    Turning Your 401k into Retirement Income

    “If you fail to plan, you are planning to fail!” While Benjamin Franklin was probably not referring to what he …Read More »
  • Are Fixed Index Annuities Best for Retirees?

    Are Fixed Index Annuities Best for Retirees?

    “Sometimes you eat the bear; sometimes the bear eats you.” – AnonymousHow would you like to make a portion of …Read More »
  • Why are Annuities an Excellent Alternative Asset Class?

    Why are Annuities an Excellent Alternative Asset Class?

    What goes up but does not come down? No, this is not the start of some riddle to be answered …Read More »

View Our Newest Videos! Subscribe Now
  • Annuity Guys Videos - Annuity Answers
  • New Annuity Guys Videos
    Our Entertaining & Informative
     Saturday Morning Video Blog
  • Timely Retirement & Annuity Issues - Easy Opt Out


  • Sell in May and Go Away or Buy Annuities?

    Sell in May and Go Away or Buy Annuities?

    Life is full of profound statements and sayings that stick in our minds. For investors and brokers, the saying “sell …Read More »
  • Hybrid Annuities as an Inflation Hedge

    Hybrid Annuities as an Inflation Hedge

    Inflation – this one word strikes terror in the hearts of many retirees on a fixed income.Never to fear, we have a cost of …Read More »
  • Relying on Annuities for Retirement Pensions

    Relying on Annuities for Retirement Pensions

    The private sector has been bailing on providing pensions for employees over the last few decades. Now, it appears legislation to …Read More »
  • A Lump Sum Buyout or Keep Your Pension –  Which is Best?

    A Lump Sum Buyout or Keep Your Pension – Which is Best?

    It is a statistical fact that “Retirees love their pensions”. Studies consistently show that pensions are favored over qualified retirement savings plans …Read More »
  • Why Should Anyone Rely on an Annuity?

    Why Should Anyone Rely on an Annuity?

    By protecting your income foundation with an annuity or annuities — and including Social Security and/or a pension as non-commercial …Read More »
  • China Tariffs – Market Corrections – Effects on Index Annuities

    China Tariffs – Market Corrections – Effects on Index Annuities

    Market’s are so unpredictable that “the experts” are frequently – DEAD WRONG! Unfortunately, you rarely here about their failed predictions, …Read More »
  • Annuities vs (IUL) Indexed Universal Life – How do they compare?

    Annuities vs (IUL) Indexed Universal Life – How do they compare?

    What are the differences between a hybrid index annuity and an (IUL) index universal life policy? Wow! Steve, we thought we …Read More »
  • Lifetime Annuity Income: Annuitize or Control Your Money with Income Riders

    Lifetime Annuity Income: Annuitize or Control Your Money with Income Riders

    Do you have to annuitize an annuity to get **guaranteed lifetime income? No, not if the annuity has an income rider.If …Read More »
Get Newly Released Annuity Guys® Videos on Saturday Mornings
  • Annuity Guys Videos - Annuity Answers
  • New Annuity Guys Videos
    Our Entertaining & Informative
     Saturday Morning Video Blog
  • Timely Retirement & Annuity Issues - Easy Opt Out


  • Annuities Make Life Better for Retirees – Study Reports

    Annuities Make Life Better for Retirees – Study Reports

    Would you rather be happy and optimistic in retirement or worried about spending too much? We know it sounds like …Read More »
  • Can Annuities Create Your Highest Retirement Income?

    Can Annuities Create Your Highest Retirement Income?

    Which of these two statements about retirement income do you find more appealing?My retirement income is contractually **guaranteed to meet …Read More »
  • Annuities: What Percentage Should Be in Your Retirement Portfolio?

    Annuities: What Percentage Should Be in Your Retirement Portfolio?

    The answer is… 50 percent (NOT!!!) — want to know why many insurance sales agents might say that?It’s nice when …Read More »
  • Identifying Unethical Annuity Advisors

    Identifying Unethical Annuity Advisors

    Practicing as a financial advisor is an honorable profession that is dishonored when its practitioners employ abusive and deceptive sales …Read More »
  • Can Hybrid Annuities Beat Market Returns?

    Can Hybrid Annuities Beat Market Returns?

    Do you remember the story of the tortoise and the hare? Hybrid annuities might be compared to the tortoise in …Read More »
  • How Do Index Annuities Pay Higher Interest?

    How Do Index Annuities Pay Higher Interest?

    Okay, what’s the catch? How is it possible that a fixed index annuity (FIA) can eliminate market risk and earn higher interest than standard fixed annuities …Read More »
  • Market Volatility is Back! Are MarketFree™ Annuities an Answer?

    Market Volatility is Back! Are MarketFree™ Annuities an Answer?

    Timing is everything. Unfortunately, 99 percent people who say they are only in the stock market when it is going up …Read More »
  • Are Annuities Best in a Difficult Economy?

    Are Annuities Best in a Difficult Economy?

    Dick and Eric reflect on a email they received this week highlighting a Tony Robbins video (see below) on the …Read More »
  • Hybrid Annuities have too many moving parts… Says Who?

    Hybrid Annuities have too many moving parts… Says Who?

    What makes a Hybrid Annuity different from a Fixed Annuity? Answer: index strategies, an income rider, and the contractual **guarantees associated …Read More »
  • Are Annuities Best for Income or Growth?

    Are Annuities Best for Income or Growth?

    You have heard the old saying, “you can’t have your cake and eat it too!” But what if you could?Retirees …Read More »

 

Empowering Annuity Reference Book

 
Start Reading Now - Instant Download
  • Annuity Guys Reference Book - 250 pages of Annuity Facts

  • "The New Retirement"
    Annuity Reference Book 
    Free Instant Download
  • Confidential - Easy Opt Out

 
Comprehensive Site Terms and Disclosure | Privacy Policy | Copyright © 2023 Annuity Guys®


  ** Guarantees, including optional benefits, are backed by the claims-paying ability of the issuer, and may contain limitations, including surrender charges, which may affect policy values. Annuities are not FDIC insured and it is possible to lose money.
Annuities are insurance products that require a premium to be paid for purchase.
Annuities do not accept or receive deposits and are not to be confused with bank issued financial instruments.
During all video segments, Dick and Eric are referring to Fixed Annuities unless otherwise specified.


  *Retirement Planning and annuity purchase assistance may be provided by Eric Judy or by referral to a recommended, experienced, Fiduciary Investment Advisor in helping Annuity Guys website visitors. Dick Van Dyke semi-retired from his Investment Advisory Practice in 2012 and now focuses on this educational Annuity Guys Website. He still maintains his insurance license in good standing and assists his current clients.
Annuity Guys' vetted and recommended Fiduciary Financial Planners are required to be properly licensed in assisting clients with their annuity and retirement planning needs. (Due diligence as a client is still always necessary when working with any advisor to check their current standing.)



  # Investors should consider the investment objectives, risks, charges and expenses of a variable annuity and its underlying investment options. The current prospectus and underlying prospectuses, which are contained in the same document, provide this and other important information. Please contact an Investment Professional or the issuing Company to obtain the prospectuses. Please read the prospectuses carefully before investing or sending money.


  ^ Investors should consider investment objectives, risk, charges, and expenses carefully before investing. This and other important information is contained in the fund prospectuses and summary prospectuses, which can be obtained from a financial professional and should be read carefully before investing.


  ^ Eric Judy offers advisory services through Client One Securities, LLC an Investment Advisor. Annuity Guys Ltd. and Client One Securities, LLC are not affiliated.


1.2k SHARES